Food Diaries 101

Food Diaries 101

Posted on 18. Jan, 2010 by in Feed Your Body

So it’s that time of year when so many of us are trying to cinch in our belt and stick to our resolutions.  If your resolution includes improving your diet and/or losing weight, here’s your secret tool: a food diary.

In a 2008 study by the Kaiser Permanente Center for Health Research, participants who kept food journals lost almost double the weight of their nonjournaling counterparts.

Could it really be true that a simple paper and pen can have such a huge impact on your health and wellness efforts?

YES!

And here’s why–there’s something magical about writing things down.  It’s like, psychologically, certain things don’t exist until we’ve actually written them down (like those 3 Krispy Kremes you downed in your car on the way to work).  We already discussed how this principle applies to goals in general in my New Year’s post “How to Make Your Resolutions Stick”, but it certainly is true for getting a handle on your food intake as well.  You might be surprised how often you pop in a handful of peanuts or snitch a quick Snickers bar without even thinking about it.  There’s nothing like a food diary to make you look your diet right between the eyes.

5 Simple Steps to Begin Your Food Diary

1.  All you need is a notebook and some paper.  There are also plenty of forms you can download online (see the links below), but they really aren’t necessary.

2.  Decide what your goal is.  If you want to track calories, you’ll want to be sure to check nutrition labels or have a calorie counter resource available so you can track calories along with your food.  If you want to track the overall balance of your diet, you may want to record how many servings of each type of food group you consume, and compare it with the FDA recommendations.  If you want to track your eating habits in general, you may want to record why you decided to eat every time you head for the refrigerator.

3.  If you are new to food diaries, it is very important that you actually measure the food you take in.  To write down 1 peach, is fine.  But, to write down 1 bowl of Captain Crunch is not.  The trouble with most Americans is that they have no concept of what a serving size is.  Even if they are educated enough to be checking labels, they have no idea if they’ve poured themselves 1 serving or 4 servings.  For your quick breakfast, you should measure and record the exact amount of cereal and milk.  For example:

1 1/2 c Captain Crunch cereal (2 servings & 240 calories)

1/2 banana  (50 calories)

1 c  milk        (90 calories)

As you become acquainted with what serving sizes actually look like, you will be able to make much more informed choices in the future.  Obviously, it’s initially a pain to carry that measuring cup around the kitchen, but remember, this is only for a short period of time and it is essential to gaining a full understanding of how much food you consume.

4.  Record at least 1 typical weekday and 1 typical weekend day.  Some people are very disciplined in their diet all week long and then go for a cookie dough extravaganza on the weekends.  Try to keep the days you record as close to typical as possible.  Remember the whole point is to find out where your diet currently stands.  It’s even better to record up to a week.

5.  When you’ve met your goal, whether it be to lose weight, to balance your diet more healthfully, or to analyze the psychological underpinnings of why you eat, STOP keeping a food diary.  Think of a food diary as a great tool to supercharge your fitness results, but not as a way of life.  Food diaries can easily spin into unhealthy obsessions that lead to anxiety and unhappiness.

4 Responses to “Food Diaries 101”

  1. Nate

    18. Jan, 2010

    Isn’t tracking calories a bad indicator of an eating disorder though?

    I’ve read articles about how “Calorie Counting” is one of the signs of eating issues. It said the following:

    “Extreme calorie counting can occur in individuals suffering from an eating disorder. They will often make sure whatever they eat contains little-to-no fats, butter, sugar etc… You may also catch them keeping track of their calories in a small notepad.”

    You can read the rest of the article titled 10 Signs You May Have an Eating Disorder for further information.

    I guess the thing I’d be leery of are the people who don’t really NEED to track calories that let this become an obsession they can’t control. I can see the importance of tracking what you eat if eating is, in and of itself, something you’re addicted to; but for many people, this idea is a waste of time at best.

    Interested to hear your thoughts.

    Reply to this comment
    • Becky

      19. Jan, 2010

      Yes, tracking calories can be a sign of an eating disorder. However, at the end of the article you linked, the following quote is found:

      “* Please note: These signs are not necessarily indicators of an eating disorder.”

      My purpose in this article is not to encourage people to keep a food diary–they are not for everyone. Like I mentioned in tip #5, if you are the type of person who already feels anxiety about what you eat and carefully plan your meals, keeping a food diary can spin you into an addictive disordered pattern.

      However, if you are the type of person who doesn’t think twice about what or when you eat and you are struggling to control your weight, a food diary can be an essential tool in your weight loss success.

      Thanks for the thoughtful and well-researched comment!

      Reply to this comment
  2. Natalie Salt

    26. Jan, 2010

    This is an interesting thought. I’ve noticed that the two days that I have written down for class are not very balanced. Some days I feel like I have a better handle on eat foods from each area, but I’ve found that I certainly don’t eat enough fruits and vegetables. I guess that’s going to be part of my new years resolution!

    Reply to this comment
    • admin

      28. Jan, 2010

      That’s a great start to balancing your diet! When you fill up on fruits and veggies, the junk food disappears from your diet, because you’re already full. Thanks for the comment!

      Reply to this comment

Leave a Reply